IT Project Recovery: Bullhorn Re-Implementation Success for Nicholas Associates

From failed go-live to fully functioning CRM, The Possibility Partnership delivered operational stability, happier users, and reduced cost-to-hire.

Key deets:

Who:

Nicholas Associates Group (NAG)

Where:

Sheffield HQ, UK-wide

What:

IT Project Recovery – Bullhorn CRM re-implementation

When:

October 2024 – March 2025

How did we help?

When Nicholas Associates Group’s first Bullhorn implementation failed, the business was left exposed. Legacy CRMs had been switched off, but Bullhorn wasn’t fit for purpose. Recruiters were stuck with broken processes, staff morale was sinking, and costs were rising.

Having worked with us before at Cordant People, COO Kelly Kendall knew exactly where to turn. She brought in The Possibility Partnership for an initial day of consultancy with the C-suite. That short engagement quickly evolved into full IT Project Recovery, with TPP reporting directly to the board — CEO, CFO and COO — to take control of the failing project and deliver results.

“Bullhorn simply wasn’t working for us — processes weren’t built, recruiters were frustrated, and operations were suffering. The Possibility Partnership came in, took full control, and got us back on track. They worked side by side with the business, rebuilt the project properly, and delivered a CRM our people could finally rely on.”

Kate Underwood, Business Analyst, Nicholas Associates Group.

The challenge:
failed implementation, frustrated recruiters

The original Bullhorn project had gone live without embedding business processes. The result? Recruiters couldn’t do their jobs effectively, operations ground down with manual workarounds, and staff frustration boiled over.

With the legacy systems gone, the business had no safety net. Nicholas Associates Group needed a recovery plan — fast.

cloud migration services
AWS cloud architects

The solution:
accountability, structure and a steady hand

The Possibility Partnership stepped in with clear accountability and full autonomy over the IT applications team. Reporting directly into the board, we:

  • Removed the IT Manager from the project to reset governance and accountability.
  • Worked with Bullhorn Professional Services to properly capture business requirements.
  • Ensured those requirements were built, tested, trained out, and taken live.
  • Brought order, communication and confidence back to a project that had lost its way.

This wasn’t about patching holes — it was a full project recovery, with TPP steering both technology and operations towards success.

The result:
a CRM that works for the business

160

Users brought back on board with Bullhorn

6

Months to recover and re-implement CRM

35%

Reduction in time-to-hire across recruitment operations

By the end of the recovery, Nicholas Associates Group finally had a CRM that delivered real business value.

“Project recovery isn’t about pointing fingers — it’s about fixing what matters. By reporting straight into the board and working hand-in-hand with the business, we turned a failing CRM into a tool that actually delivered results. For us, success means making the complex simple and giving people the confidence to get on with their jobs.”

– The Possibility Partnership

Stabilised operations

Bullhorn re-implemented correctly, with processes fully embedded.

Empowered recruiters

Staff could finally use Bullhorn effectively, without clunky workarounds.

Operational efficiency

Faster time-to-hire and reduced cost-to-hire delivered measurable ROI.

Improved Morale

Confidence in the system restored, with sentiment across teams swinging positive.

Need more feel-good tech tales?

Category

A new CRM won’t fix unclear processes, poor data or weak ownership. Before you replace the platform, work out what job it needs to do better.

Category

AI can save time in recruitment, but only when the problem, data, workflow and human oversight are clear. Start with one useful use case and get the foundations right.

Ready to go remote?

Enjoy fully flexible working – and reduced costs – with our cloud migration services. Book your discovery call today to find out how!